Heraldic law
The Scope of Heraldic Law
Within heraldry, the discipline concerned with the right to bear arms and the conditions governing their use is known as heraldic law (címerjog). Its foundations were established in the 13th century, largely through the work of early heraldists who were also trained as jurists. Heraldic law was first comprehensively addressed by Felix Hauptmann in his work Das Wappenrecht (Bern, 1897).
Heraldic law developed during the era of “living heraldry” and was primarily based on customary law rather than codified statutes. Its rules can be divided into two main categories: the first pertains to who is entitled to bear arms, thus falling under public law; the second concerns the right to specific arms, the modes of acquisition and usage, their authentication, and the grounds for their forfeiture, which belong to the domain of private law.
The Legal Basis for the Use of Arms
There are two primary legal foundations for the use of arms:
- Inherent/Noble right: Applicable to noble families, nations, cities, counties, and ecclesiastical dignitaries.
- Royal privilege: Applicable to bourgeois families and corporations granted the right to bear arms by the sovereign as a special favor, despite not being entitled to such arms based on their public status; and to noble families whose arms were specifically granted by the monarch.
The Nature of Heraldic Law
The right to bear arms is private in nature. It generally signifies that a person is entitled to use a specific coat of arms, not that they may bear any arbitrary arms or those belonging to another. An individual may have the right to use several coats of arms, each with a different legal basis (e.g., as a personal family coat of arms, or under other capacities such as national, corporate, or “pretension” arms).
When marshaling arms or creating composite shields, these legal distinctions are reflected in the arrangement of the charges and divisions. One must consider the legal nature, significance, and rank of the arms being combined, particularly regarding whether they are arms of dignity or patronage. Arms of the same status should not be commingled with those of a different legal standing, and the more significant arms are entitled to the position of honor. In the case of state arms, the order of the monarch’s titles prevails. The monarch’s family arms usually occupy the escutcheon of pretense (boglárpajzs), while arms of dignity, patronage, and honorary arms precede the family arms.
The right to arms does not apply to the physical object—such as the shield or helmet—but to the use of the emblem displayed upon it. Thus, one may sell a shield or helmet bearing arms without transferring the right to use the arms themselves. The right to arms is a non-pecuniary right, recognized by legal systems as a distinct right akin to a person’s name.
Acquisition and Usage of Arms
Originally, arms were acquired through assumption, but royal grants gradually became the standard. Although for a long time there was no specific law prohibiting the use of assumed arms, it was not considered a desirable practice even at the time the earliest Hungarian letters patent were issued. This is evidenced by the texts of many early armals, which state that all noble privileges and arms derive from royal authority.
Arms could also be acquired through purchase, gift, or adoption; however, the validity of such transactions eventually required royal approval. While some burgher families gradually ascended to the nobility through the use of arms, István Werbőczy emphasized that a coat of arms in itself does not prove noble descent, nor is it necessary to produce one to verify noble status. Even in the 18th century, a coat of arms was not considered sufficient proof of nobility, as confirmed by royal decrees issued on April 16 and October 11, 1732.
Armorial Usurpation and Heraldic Forgery
The domain of heraldic law also included action against unlawful usage. Armorial usurpation refers to the unauthorized use of arms belonging to another, while heraldic forgery involves the fabrication or misuse of letters patent or other documents. Both offenses violated the order of heraldic usage and were utilized to illegitimately substantiate noble status or other rights.
While many countries enacted specific legislation to prevent these abuses, Hungary did not do so until 1883, and even that law dealt exclusively with the unauthorized use of the national coat of arms. Nevertheless, armorial usurpation was considered a punishable offense in Hungary. This is indicated by a 1416 letter patent issued by King Sigismund of Luxembourg, which imposed a fine of ten marks of gold on any usurpers of the arms granted to the Jánoki and Zászi families. Hungarian legal practice rarely brought such cases to court. A known example is that of the Pribék family, who unlawfully used the arms of the Nagymihályi family; though litigation reportedly ensued, the lack of specific statutory regulations allowed the Pribék family to continue using the contested arms.
The History of Heraldic Law
Initially, knights, and later burghers and peasants, assumed arms freely without royal documentation, relying on tradition and customary law, which were accepted by the community and the sovereign. From the mid-14th century, monarchs began issuing letters patent confirmed by seals, creating “grant arms” (adománycímerek). The first known Hungarian grant of arms was issued by King Louis the Great to the city of Kassa in 1369.
In a 1327 “augmentation” charter, King Charles I of Hungary granted Master Dancs, Count of Zólyom, the right to change the silver portions of his arms to gold on his shield, crest, and banner, provided he joined the royal campaign. He further decreed that if Master Dancs encountered any knight wearing similar arms, he was entitled to seize them.
Bartolo de Sassoferrato and subsequent jurist-heraldists argued that royal approval was required for the legitimate bearing of arms. Monarchs recognized that issuing letters patent was a significant source of revenue, leading to the establishment of chanceries and heraldic offices, which reinforced the legal perspective of heraldry. By the 18th century, J. A. Philippi shifted the focus, stating: “The use of arms is a manifestation not of legal history, but of cultural history.” By the late 19th century, commercial heraldic enterprises in the Monarchy began selling “burgher arms,” a practice that continues today in Western Europe and the United States, where names are sometimes used to market “family coats of arms” for profit, sometimes even via automated systems.
In the United States, the assumption of arms is unregulated, allowing anyone to create and use their own (arms of assumption). However, this varies by jurisdiction; for instance, while Donald Trump used a modified version of a pre-existing private coat of arms for his businesses in the U.S., he was required by the Lord Lyon King of Arms to obtain a new, officially sanctioned coat of arms for his golf estates in Scotland due to strict heraldic regulations.
Heraldic Law in Hungary
In Hungary, a “cult of heraldry” never developed to the extent seen in the West. According to István Werbőczy, coats of arms had no legal significance; they were merely decorative, not essential, accompaniments to nobility.
Under Hungarian law, the use of noble titles and arms was prohibited by Section 3(2) of Act IV of 1947, which remains in force: “The use of noble titles, noble coats of arms and badges, or terms referring to noble lineage (de genere) is prohibited.” As the law contains no specific sanctions, the use of arms is de jure prohibited, but de facto carries no direct legal consequences.
Burgher Arms in Hungary
Among the burgher families of the Kingdom of Hungary, those of German origin were most likely to use inherited arms brought from their homelands. However, this remained uncommon, as few families possessed the prestige or financial background to maintain their own arms. Documentation of such usage is scarce. Notable exceptions include the arms of the Spielmann, Prückler, Lenz, and Topits families. For instance, József Prückler (1778–1848), a master baker and citizen of Pest, used a family wax seal. His shield depicted a budunka (a wooden vessel), with a crest featuring identical figures between two black eagle wings; the helmet lacked a crown, as that was a noble privilege. In the Buda Castle District, a burgher coat of arms belonging to the family of Hedvig Spielmann, wife of János Asbóth (1858–?), was once displayed on the façade of their home alongside her husband’s arms.